ππ₯π’π―π’ π¦π° π°π±π―π¬π«π€ π¦π«π±π’π―π’π°π± π¦π« π£π²π«π‘π¦π«π€ π±π₯π’ ππ―π¬π§π’π π± π£π²π©π©πΆ.
ππ’ ππ―π’ π¦π« π±π₯π’ ππ―π¬π π’π°π° π¬π£ π°π±π―π²π π±π²π―π¦π«π€ π±π₯π’ ππ―π¬ππ¬π°ππ© ππ―π¬π π’π°π° π΄π¦π±π₯ π±π₯π¦π° π³π’π―πΆ π£π¦π―π°π± π’π΅ππͺππ©π’.
3 Likes
Great idea and concept, finds my support.
2 Likes
This is awesome and youβve demonstrated your dedication and time investment even before funding. We should definitely move forward regardless of the feedback Iβm going to give below so donβt let this slow down getting the proposal teed up.
A few thoughts:
- Donβt try to over engineer it. The guild fights, guild management, leveling system, etc is all awesome, but I would try to get a minimum viable product out and running first. If we can do all that fantastic, but less is more imo. Maybe this is where having different milestones may be helpful.
- Be careful with betting and in-game currency. I would recommend in-game currency is built in such a way that it has no value outside of the game that way you are not worrying about securities, etc. Not legal advice, but as simple thing is to make the ERC20 non-transferrable if thatβs what you plan on using (see Toadstoolz for an implementation of this approach). You may have a different vision though in terms of how that works that gets around this.
I would also consider any incremental costs outside of development⦠E.g. do you need any help from artists in the community to create animations / visuals? If so you should include some funds for them as part of this ask.
Overall looks great! And your work has been awesome so far!
4 Likes
Welcome to the conclave Bright.
Full faith in 0xG development, I approve.
Only suggestion is to see some sort of Game Design Document (GDD) for proposals like these. Doesnβt have to be etched in stone, but having a GDD as part of any game-oriented proposals would help folks understand the intended mechanics and design of the game a bit better.
Most of us know what youβre cooking since itβs been in the public for a minute now, but with this being the first game proposal, it would be good to set precedent with even a light GDD before it goes to WIP status so that everyone can get on the same page.
3 Likes
Good points, the development plan is to split it up and release as each feature is completed along with beta tests rather than attempt to finish the whole thing in one go.
With the in-game currency it will be entirely off-chain so we wonβt have to worry about that. The betting Iβm thinking itβll be with ETH but betting would be last thing to implement I think imo.
Good point about the visuals and stuff, I think we could have a separate proposal when the time comes that Iβm at that stage because itβll be a good bit before thatβs important.
2 Likes
Good idea yea, Iβll work on one asap 
2 Likes
I guess, the most important suggestions were already made above (MVP, milestones, GDD).
I would maybe only ask you to express if youβd be willing to make it open source (or hand over to the community) at some point or with some conditions - for example, in case you wonβt be able to keep developing it/maintaining it in the future. Like we all know - all things die.
1 Like
If Iβm not able to keep developing/maintaining it in the future Iβd be fine with making it open source. Iβm full time web3 and planning on staying around permanently so if WAGDIE continues Iβll very likely still be around to maintain or develop new features if the community needs it.
Iβll always be able to be reached too during and after development.
4 Likes
Battle Battle! i love battle 
4 Likes
Welcome to the Conclave.
1 Like
Hello @OxG,
The Conclave Representatives would like to move your proposal to a final stage. However, we need to clarify the following in order to do so:
You outline 3-4 project milestones which we will align with community treasury allocations. Conclave representatives agree that a first payment should be provided before the first milestone.
You assent to subject this project to any future, Conclave sanctioned auditors should it involve wallet interaction mechanics at any point in the future.
Best,
CR
4 Likes
Not sure I understand what βYou outline 3-4 project milestones which we will align with community treasury allocations.β means sorry.
Yes any smart contracts Iβd gladly have the conclave sanctioned auditors look at before.
As of now the only interaction with your wallet in my game is the initial log in button which is simply a signed message.
2 Likes
This is how you could create milestones. 1st down payment if proposal passes. 2nd payment after X feature is done, 3rd payment after Y feature is done etc.
2 Likes
As the creator of the WAGDIE Tournament of Death and Bald Savior vs. Burner fight, I 100% support this proposal.
Additionally, 0xG is on our multi-sig for the prizes for the tournament - I havenβt worked closely with him, but heβs always been a pleasure to interact with, super helpful and supportive to me, and open to feedback and conversation about everything weβre both doing.
My thoughts:
- Ideal high impact project - I think this type of project is one of the most effecient/best things we can do with community wallet
- Amazing value - It would be impossible to get a better price than this
- Reward High Impact Community Effort - We should reward community members who put this much effort into something with such high impact/potential
- Community Heat - Weβve seen some heat around this type of experience with the Tournament of Death
- Social proof - Iβve seen 0xG been a positive member of community
- Proof of work - heβs already built a lot, showing that he can execute
If we donβt fund this, Iβm not sure what weβd fund frankly. Godspeed!
5 Likes
@0xG You should be able to edit this draft. Please get it prepared for Final Draft, make any changes you see fit etc.
I have made some changes mostly towards the end, also suggested a vote for the payment amount if possible.
Let me know if you need anything else from me
1 Like